
Before I give my report on the Lessons and Carols service this evening, two quick stories:
Story 1: In the mid-60s, my home town church built a new sanctuary. Among a few controversial design elements, none was more so than the placing of the choir loft in a balcony at the rear of the sanctuary. In fact, I'm not sure that this doesn't remain a point of contention in that congregation more than four decades later. But the reason for the design always seemed to me to be a sound one. It is a symbolic way of acknowledging that choir music is not a performance for the congregation, but an act of worship directed to God.
Story 2: There was a scene in a TV series some years ago in which a string quartet made up of amateur musicians performed a recital before a small audience. After the performance, one of the musicians lamented that she had not played to the standard she had set for herself. The group’s leader consoled her, saying "I believe the audience was oblivious to the nuances of our performance." My wife and I found the remark amusing, and it has become a catchphrase for us.
Okay, now I'll try to tie those stories to this evening's service.
My view (a common one, based on comments I heard from other choir members) is that, overall, our singing was good. But there were exceptions here and there, and notably one carol that did not go as planned. So, how to grade the performance?
Answer: The question is misguided. Lessons and Carols was not a "performance" to be graded (see Story 1 above). It was a service of praise and worship. Isn't it presumptuous to think that God discounts musical praise when He hears a flat note, an error of timing or dynamics, or any other failing?
Still, while it was a worship service, not a concert, it’s still true that the congregation was of course listening to the music. That's where Story 2 comes in. Did some people notice a flaw or two? Probably. But it's likely that relatively few did, and even fewer cared; because God was in the sanctuary as His people were reminded, in word and in song, of the Greatest Gift